War in Ukraine: Canada blocks the naturalization of a woman... for criticism of Russia

Arriving in 2019 from Russia, Maria Kartasheva has gone through a nightmare in recent months in Canada. The Russian, 30, had the unpleasant surprise of seeing her immigration application rejected during the naturalization ceremony. A pro-democracy activist, she could even have been expelled from the country due to her conviction in absentia by a Russian court for “disinformation” in the context of the conflict in Ukraine. A critic of the Kremlin, the young woman was prosecuted for two articles written in Ottawa. According to the Canadian Penal Code, immigration rules ensure that a citizenship applicant charged with a crime in another country can have their application rejected.

The media commotion caused by this extremely rare case forced the Canadian Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship, Marc Miller, to intervene on X. “The eligibility rules are designed to bar access to Canadian citizenship by criminals, not to repress or punish legitimate political dissidents, assures the elected official. Miss Kartasheva will not be deported and has been invited to become a Canadian citizen.”

At the same time, the good news fell during the young woman's lunch (5:00 p.m. GMT): an email inviting her to perform her ceremony a few hours later (8:00 p.m. GMT). “I have the impression that I will not believe that it happened even after the ceremony,” she assured the Canadian channel CBC. For a long time, I had the impression that no one was interested in this matter.” She hopes that her misadventure will demonstrate “that Canada will support the Russians in Canada who oppose the war, and that we will be able to sleep peacefully.”

For the young woman, the troubles began at the end of 2022. She had learned through her family that she had been accused by the Russian authorities of a “wartime offense” for having “deliberately disseminated false information” on the troops of his country of origin. In question, her blog where she regularly publishes posts on the Ukraine-Russia conflict.

In one of the two publications in question dating from March 2022, on the Boutcha massacre, we can read: “Tell me that before the arrival of Russian troops, all these people were alive and walking on their own bicycles. I don't know why it was so ingrained in my memory that there were bikes everywhere, and the dead people riding them, apparently, were going somewhere.

Involved, the young woman also participated in other actions, by demonstrating in front of the Russian embassy in Ottawa or by developing a group called Russian Canadian Democratic Alliance.

Russia's fake news law, publicized for its impact on the country's politicians or journalists, is also used against citizens of the country critical of the Kremlin's actions. As a result, Russian judge Elena Lenskaya ordered the arrest of Maria Kartasheva in absentia, then last November, the Basnmany District Court in Moscow sentenced her to eight years of imprisonment based on posts published on her blog .

When she learned in April 2023 that an arrest warrant had been issued against her, the young woman submitted an application for citizenship in Canada and informed the department responsible for immigration (IRCC: Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada) of the accusations made against him. During May, she received an invitation to her citizenship ceremony.

Maria Kartasheva appears at the ceremony on June 7, alongside her husband. Before taking the oath, an officer asks a common question, whether a person has been the subject of criminal charges. She raises her hand, then an official asks her to leave the ceremony while her husband continues the process and obtains Canadian citizenship. The session ends. She was unable to swear allegiance to the Crown.

Also readWar in Ukraine: Canadian parliament receives Nazi veteran during Zelensky's visit

“I felt betrayed because I hoped to be safe here in Canada,” said the young woman, in comments relayed by Radio Canada on January 5. I was heartbroken. But I was also trying to stay positive, because it was still my husband's ceremony, so I didn't want to ruin the day for him. I know Canada does not support the war. I know they agree that Russia is silencing people who oppose the war. So I thought it was such an obvious situation that it wouldn’t be a problem.”

How can we explain this turnaround? Section 372 (1) of the Criminal Code of Canada states that anyone who "commits an offense with intent to harm or alarm any person, transmits or causes to be transmitted by letter or any means of telecommunications information that he knows to be false” risks up to two years in prison. The ministry confirmed to him in December that his conviction in Russia corresponded to this scenario. “It’s a normal country,” she lamented about Canada. You would think that no one would consider me a criminal for opposing the war, but ultimately that seems to be the case. That does not make any sense !"

Also readWar in Ukraine: how has the front line evolved in 2023?

The young woman, who works in the technology sector in Ottawa, faced deportation to Russia. “I know the chances are low, but so many things have gone wrong,” she feared. How could I not fear being deported?”

Canada has, however, been a leading ally of Ukraine since the start of the Russian invasion in 2022. The Canadian government welcomed President Volodymyr Zelensky at the end of September, promising him financial aid. He also imposed sanctions on Russian personalities, notably... the judge responsible for the arrest of Maria Kartasheva, Elena Lenskaya.