Post a Comment Print Share on Facebook


When the second medical opinion is worth

Anita Müller (Name changed) was taken aback, he stated to her, the doctor, and schedule an appointment for Surgery, to have your varicose veins examined. Been a while, they strained their tired and heavy legs. The surgeon has been recommended, but she has a bad feeling about this.

Because on the one hand, Anita Müller respect of an engagement, and on the other hand, the surgeon of the risks as well as the advantages and disadvantages of this intervention could not explain so conclusive, that she could form an opinion. You would like to hear what says another expert.

First of all, you are still afraid of something, to draw on the Expertise of your surgeon is in doubt. After members have you encouraged to consult with finally, however, a second expert.

luckily, Because the other doctor examined by means of ultrasound, as well blood from the legs is transported. He notes that the tired legs of Anita Müller is probably connected to one of the few varicose veins and there is no compelling reason for surgery.

in other words: The surgical removal of veins would have eased the discomfort by Anita Müller. Under these circumstances, it dispensed with the surgical procedure.

Paid by the health insurance.

the goal of a medical second opinion is not only to detect flaws, such as Daniel Tapernoux, medical Advisor at Swiss Foundation patient protection (SPO), explained, but also Alternatives, weigh them against each other. He illustrates this with the example of the treatment of prostate cancer: "Because there are different methods with different risks and benefits." In the case of planned operations Tapernoux advises to consult at negative gut feeling a second doctor. Often the Patient will decide for himself but, if he was against a proposed surgical procedure skeptical.

The SPO recommends that you check beforehand with the insurance provider if you pay for a second opinion. In fact, the health insurance act does not explicitly funding of Second opinions. However, patients need to think about the head. So it means, for example, in the case of the health insurance Helsana, that you appreciate it when patients asked about the planned intervention critically.

"A second opinion is never wrong, especially for private patients."Felix Schneuwly, Comparis

two main reasons contribute to the fact that insurance companies cover such costs: first, you yourself have an interest in second opinions, because they lead more often to lower the cost of treatment. And secondly, it is small amounts, the fall is of little weight. "A second opinion is never wrong – this is especially true for private patients, since these are more frequently insured operates as a Basic," explains Felix Schneuwly, health expert at the comparison service Comparis, in allusion to the potential savings in treatment costs.

it is Undisputed that patients have the right to a second opinion is entitled to. A doctor's duty is to the patient records to the present case, if someone wants to seek another expert evaluation. The vast majority of Doctors manage the professional and support patients.

consultation with the house doctor

However, as patients go without the extra insurance? It is best to take with your doctor consultation who knows in the rule of experts and the patients can assign. For the second opinion ideally, you should select a doctor who works in another hospital or in another Canton. Tapernoux advises to consult experts from a different area of expertise, perform no operations: "he Who consults, for example, due to back problems after the surgeon to a rheumatologist, can get new and valuable insights."

Finally, there are also Internet platforms where Experts judge the experts solely on the basis of documents, a case, and the finding within a few days. If the website is the used specialists be together with the place of work specifically and in a verifiable manner, which provides a certain guarantee for a serious evaluation.

apart First and second opinion, diametrically opposite, is sometimes recommended to even a third opinion. Tapernoux advises, however, to restraint, as to a lot of different expert opinions can confuse the patient. Often it is more fruitful to look again at the conversation with the Doctors involved.

Sensitive interventions

it is more Difficult to identify specific interventions where a second opinion is displayed. The experts advise against it, since the cases differ individually. Evidence is a list, which switches the comparison portal Comparis on the topic of second opinion on his Website. It listed, among others: surgery, varicose veins, cornea transplant, scheduled cesarean section, removal of the uterus, bunion surgery, disc surgery, Insertion of artificial joints, surgery, cataracts, arthroscopy, tonsil surgery, or removal of gall bladder.


Created: 12.05.2019, 18:50 PM

Your Name
Post a Comment
Characters Left:
Your comment has been forwarded to the administrator for approval.×
Warning! Will constitute a criminal offense, illegal, threatening, offensive, insulting and swearing, derogatory, defamatory, vulgar, pornographic, indecent, personality rights, damaging or similar nature in the nature of all kinds of financial content, legal, criminal and administrative responsibility for the content of the sender member / members are belong.