"We feel a little forgotten", regrets this 50-year-old teacher, who lost her house in the storm. "We thought they (the authorities) were going to send aid, water, supplies and other things, but they told us no, and that we had to leave," she adds.
Until Wednesday, Matlacha was a little gem in southwest Florida, a fishing village with colorful wooden houses built around a wide street, where you can enjoy the sea, the blue sky, the restaurants seafood and small art galleries.
The hurricane, which according to the latest official report has caused 58 confirmed deaths in Florida - against 44 deaths previously announced - changed everything.
Three days after its passage, the coastguards, firefighters and residents of neighboring towns go there by boat to rescue the last residents who were stuck after refusing to evacuate before the storm.
Other inhabitants who had left the island made the trip in the opposite direction to see the damage.
Christian Lopez, 25, watches the jetty where emergency services are evacuating victims.
He has no intention of leaving. "I prefer to stay here rather than go elsewhere and be on the street. Here, at least, we have a small roof, we will try to repair the caravan where we live", explains the young man.
- "I have no plan" -
At the other end of Matlacha, the main street is cut by a huge crack that locals cross on a makeshift bridge made from a metal plank.
Here and there, dozens of people walk wearily, looking elsewhere. Most share the same uncertainty: they don't know where to go.
"I don't have a plan," said John Lynch, resigned. The 59-year-old man's house is sinking into the sea and he is preparing to leave.
"We have been here for 25 years (...) It is heartbreaking because this is where we planned to live the rest of our lives," he sighs.
Karen Pagliaro also doesn't know what she's going to do from now on. She has nowhere to go and the school where she works had to temporarily close due to hurricane damage. What is clear to her is that she wants to live in Matlacha.
"It's our city, we cherish it and we love being here," she said.
Near the pier, Jim Bedra is about to leave with his wife, Kathy, and their dog, Luna, on a coastguard boat. Last week, this septuagenarian wanted to evacuate the island with Kathy and their 31-year-old son, but the latter convinced him to stay where they had lived since 2013. Now he no longer has a home and his voice breaks when discussing this situation.
"We're going to stay in a shelter, I guess. It's not the retirement we were looking for," he explains, adding that he wants to return to his home state of Ohio, in the northern United States.
Before boarding the boat that is to take him to the mainland, Jim adds: "I never want to come back here."